Loading the reel…
Loading the reel…


Sherlock Holmes investigates when young women around London turn up murdered, each with a finger severed. Scotland Yard suspects a madman, but Holmes believes the killings to be part of a diabolical plot.
Status
Released

Basil Rathbone
Sherlock Holmes

Nigel Bruce
Dr. John Watson

Hillary Brooke
Lydia Marlowe

Henry Daniell
Professor James Moriarty

Paul Cavanagh
Sir George Fenwick

Matthew Boulton
Inspector Gregson
This is maybe not one of the better of the fourteen outings for Messrs. Rathbone and Bruce, but it's still a thoroughly enjoyable watch as "Holmes" and "Watson" have to get to the bottom of a mystery that involves a series of apparently unrelated killings linked only by the fact that each victim has a severed finger. No "Lestrade" this time, but Matthew Boulton is "Insp. Gregson" who together with our deductive duo, tries to get to the bottom of it all - and as their investigations deepen, they discover that their long thought dead nemesis "Prof. Moriarty" (Henry Daniell) is back and even more nasty! This also has a suitably classy, menacing performance from Hilary Brooke as femme fatale "Lydia Marlow" to keep the pot boiling before quite a tense denouement. Well worth a watch.
50/100 Sherlock Holmes hunts done a murderer who collects women's fingers. Never watched a Basil Rathbone 'Holmes' film before and I doubt that I'll watch another. Rathbone was fine but he didn't really have much of a mystery to figure out ...especially considering its main plot device was hypnotism used in a completely unrealistic manner. My biggest complaint though was the depiction of Dr. Watson as a completely clueless moron. Perhaps that was considered comic relief 80 years ago but it made no sense to me and left me sadly cringing most of the time. - DrNostromo.com

Eve Amber
Maude Fenwick

Frederick Worlock
Dr. Onslow